Happy Friday, dearests, and welcome to the Open Mic! After last week’s wonderful and heartfelt discussion, I am overjoyed to introduce you to Chad Sell, who takes us behind the scenes of his recent graphic novel Shadow Play.
—–
Since Lisaโs blog features such a wonderful combination of both art and the creative process behind it, I wanted to share some of my own experiences as a graphic novelist–particularly, what I learned when I undertook a new direction after suffering some serious setbacks and disappointment with my work.
My graphic novel Shadow Play took shape last summer, when I was in a really rough spot–I had spent the last few years running myself ragged on two ambitious graphic novels, but neither snagged me the giant book deal Iโd been hoping for. And even worse, the criticism I got from editors about those two projects undermined my confidence in both of them, and so I chose not to finish either book. It had been a harrowing process, strung out over months as rejection letters slowly trickled in.
Thereโs nothing worse in the life of an artist than looking back at the labors of your love, and seeing that theyโre ugly and misshapen, full of poorly realized characters and tepid plotlines.
I was especially disgusted by my over-reliance on stark line, stiff anatomy, and suffocating page layouts. I had spent months and months fussing over dialogue and tiny details in the artwork, but despite some pretty and playful exceptions, I couldnโt help but feel that the work was stale and soulless.
I told myself that I needed a break–like a jilted lover, I needed time to recuperate before jumping back into the dating pool. So rather than throwing myself back into another overly-ambitious project, I decided to try something… smaller.
And simpler.
No dialogue to fuss over, or panel structure to tweak, and no lines at all. No shading to second guess, no editors to appease.
And thus, Shadow Play was born!
Shadow Play first came to me as a simple little story of a boy on a lonely playground, depicted in stark silhouettes. I wanted it to be a small, short book that I could easily self-publish, even print it myself on my black and white laser printer! Whatever this strange book of shadows became, it would be entirely my own.
And so, it started. Rather than slowly and methodically working through drafts and outlines, I took a more intuitive, see-where-it-goes approach.
Weird things started happening. The young protagonist looked oddly like me as a child.
I soon found myself channeling childhood memories, the oddly poignant images of a swingset, how I was transfixed on the single magical moment of weightlessness as you jump off at full speed and reach the apex of your flight. You think, just maybe, youโve taught yourself to fly.
The images kept coming. Birds, dreams, terrifying giants, falling, and flying.
Despite the constraints of size, the simple silhouettes, and the wordlessness, I found myself revelling in the surreal imagery I found myself spinning out of nothing. Where had all this come from?
As I kept adding scenes and exploring new avenues, the book blossomed into a full graphic novel. After a few months of creative revelry, of delighted play, I was done. It was my first book to have ever actually finished, and it was all mine.
It didnโt matter what my agent thought (I was sure heโd hate it) or what the editors might say (surely it wasnโt marketable!). This strange, fever-dream of a book stood on its own.
Shadow Play had exceeded my expectations–for better, and for worse. Although it had revitalized my creativity and confidence, it had also grown to be a book much heftier than I could put together myself (unless I picked up some badass bindery skills!). So what to do?
Well, I let it sit for a while. Despite posting it online, I really wasnโt sure how to promote it. And given the track record with my previous book projects, I fully expected to look back at Shadow Play with disgust in a few months.
I started yet another book pitch for publishers, though I also began a weekly webcomic to serve as a counterweight–at least Iโd get my work out there in some way or another, regardless of book deals or profitability.
And last month, I allowed myself to revisit Shadow Play. I braced myself, fully expecting to see all of its glaring weaknesses, to second-guess the enthusiasm and excitement Iโd previously felt about it.
But… as I raced through it, I was shocked to find that I still liked it! Not only that, I was moved, compelled to finally see this project through.
It took some work–formatting, lots of layout, a few calls to local printers. But I was hellbent: I would publish this book. And so, this very week, I picked up the first copies of Shadow Play.
Iโve already signed up to exhibit at my first comics conventions this year, and Shadow Play will be my flagship title, my tiny little treasure. After years of false starts, this very graphic novelist finally has a graphic novel of his own to send out into the world.
I think we as creative people can be stymied by external forces: trends in the market, fickle editors, the constant uphill battle to get your work in front of interested eyes. But we also tend to cripple ourselves with doubt and second-guessing.
Itโs important to recognize when youโre feeling stagnant and to make a course correction. For me, it was embarking on an experimental little side-project. Setting limits and constraints (like those I set for myself with Shadow Play) will force you to try things youโd never imagined before, and you just might like what you discover in your work and yourself.
—–
Chad Sell is a full-time graphic novelist and part-time caretaker of the elderly. His personal website is The Sellout and his weekly webcomic Manta-Man can be read here: www.mantamancomics.com. His graphic novel Shadow Play can be found in its entirety here. You can also look him up on Twitter as @panja57 if youโre into that kind of thing. And feel free to e-mail him! panjacomics@gmail.com
Thank you so much, Chad! And now — the comments are open. Go to it!
Itโs important to recognize when youโre feeling stagnant and to make a course correction. For me, it was embarking on an experimental little side-project. Setting limits and constraints (like those I set for myself with Shadow Play) will force you to try things youโd never imagined before, and you just might like what you discover in your work and yourself.
Thanks so much for offering this space to present my work, Lisa!
If anyone has any questions, I’ll be watching these comments to provide whatever answers that I can!
Thank you for sharing so generously!
[…] my friend Lisa Hsia graciously allowed me to share my experience and experimentation in making Shadow Play on her marvelous art blog! So make sure to check that […]
Wow awesome artwork! And people can follow your advice no matter what work they do. Sometimes you just need to sit back and re-evaluate.
Hee, true words spoken by someone who just turned in her 2-week notice. ๐
YES, literally. I just got back from talking to my manager.
WOOHOO!!!
Congrats!!! ๐
Shra, I only know you as Lisa’s lovely sister. But want to congratulate you on your big step towards freedom. Have fun!
I should introduce my sisters (I have two) properly sometime, but just for now: Shra is a nickname I made up for her when I was little, and it’s what I call her and how most of my friends know her. Most other folks know her as Sarah. ๐ And I’m very honored to have her reading my blog so often!
Shadow Play looks great; it has such an energy about it! Thanks for sharing a bit about your process – a great suggestion too, to get started on a side project. Good luck with the book.
Chad, I peeked at “Shadow Play” last week and fell in love! I need two copies one for myself and one for my sister. I’ll definitely be contacting you later about that!
I love the way you’ve written about your work. Thank you so much for sharing. When I come to see my own mistakes (and wonder why I couldn’t see them before), I doubt myself so much that it’s hard for me to think that I can ever be good at my writing. I’ve also been longing to begin something new, and attempt it in a fresh more fulfilling way. I’m looking forward to the process of deciding what to write about and how I want to do it, while knowing that I can take my time and choose what feels best for me. I’ve been thinking simplicity, too. Reading about your journey with “Shadow Play,” gives me a little more confidence. Thanks!
Rรฉ
Thanks for such great responses! I wanted to offer a few more thoughts and some lessons I’ve learned (and am still trying to incorporate into my own work).
Young writers (and graphic novelists) are often encouraged by their teachers to focus on short works as they’re honing their craft. But it’s difficult to get excited about small, throw-away projects–for me, at least, the most compelling projects are the huge, ambitious, this-is-gonna-be-so-amazing book ideas that consume your every waking moment.
But here’s the problem with taking on too much too early: you spend a year doing the first half of your book, only to look back on your progress with horror at your earlier efforts, which prompts you to go back, spend the next six months revising (or starting from scratch), and the cycle continues. Yes, you’ll gradually improve your work, but you might not have any finished product to show after years of work! I spent two years working solely on Vreeland, which was a graphic memoir about a time of my life during which I was the primary caretaker for my grandparents. The book underwent innumerable revisions (the draft I sent to publishers was, without exaggeration, the 13th draft!) but if I were to try and finish it, I’d STILL feel compelled to go back and scrap a lot of the earlier pages.
It’s a real conundrum for any artist or writer still developing their skills.
Here’s what I suggest–it’s what I’ve been practicing over the past year, which has been one of the most productive periods of my career. If you’re compelled to work on an ambitious, book-length project, do it. Compose a rough draft (be it graphic novel, memoir, screenplay, anything!), throw all your ideas into it, and then… let it sit. You’ll need time away from it to get perspective. And while you’re letting it stew, work on something different–something with lower stakes, in a different style, possibly in an entirely different medium. You can never anticipate how your different methods of working will feed into each other!
And then, once you’ve been creatively invigorated by your “side projects,” return to your earlier draft with fresh eyes and determine where to go from there. If another revised draft is in order, do it. And once again, take a break when needed.
If you force yourself to work on only one project day in and day out, you’ll start to hate it, you’ll second guess yourself, you’ll burn out, and you’ll get in a rut. It’s crucial you find your own balance that fosters the best results.
It’s a long process. Seek help from other creative peers, and ask them for their honest responses to your work (when you’re ready to hear it).
I’ve been in the “endless revision” cycle for my graphic novel The Cardboard Kingdom for the past six months, and I’ve really benefited from taking time away from it, getting some emotional distance, and then hearing my friends’ and family’s frank criticism and suggestions for the book. When you can build up some perspective and detach yourself, you can see your work SO much more clearly and better consider constructive feedback.
And some days, you might not be able to force yourself to work on *any* of your creative projects, and that’s the time to clean your bathroom. Or go on an “art date.” Or (for me) lose yourself in an uber-geeky videogame ; )
I don’t even know where to begin–so many wonderful things to comment on! First of all, I just paid a visit to your website and immediately snapped up a copy of Shadow Play. After reading about the fascinating process leading up to its creation, I’m dying to read it in its entirety!
I’m struck by how timely your advice is for me right now. In the past week, I’ve decided to dive into a new business venture, and while it’s not a book, your suggestions are incredibly relevant. I too have a tendency to go after the ginormous, life-consuming projects, deeming the smaller ones to be “too boring and insignificant,” but I can’t tell you how many times I’ve looked back at my earlier efforts with dismay, and that’s putting it lightly.
Your thoughts are inspiring me to come up with a more manageable goal (i.e. not taking over the entire world with my business idea by, oh, next month), one that I can actually visualize myself carrying out in smaller chunks, rather than slaving away for months on end until I’m so sick of the idea that I never want to think about it again for as long as I live.
Thank you so much for sharing! I think reading your post is going to be one of those moments that I look back on years from now and sigh happily, knowing that it was the catalyst for a move in a different, more sane direction. ๐
I’m so glad to hear that the lessons learned from my own blunders has been some help to you! I checked out your work and was utterly charmed and overwhelmed by the incredible skill that goes into those gorgeous miniatures!
Heheh Well, I certainly have enough of my own mistakes to learn from–and then some–so it’s nice to mix things up and learn from someone else’s experiences for a change. ๐ And thank you for checking out my work!
And Mo, yay, I think starting small sounds good too. ๐ Especially since from what I’ve heard of your new plans, they will (at least temporarily) involve taking on more than what you’re currently doing… ! I’m sure it’ll only be a benefit to take things slowly so you can feel out the balance as you go. ๐
Definitely! I can already feel myself wanting to push, push, push, simply because I’m so excited about the new business direction, but a good dose of balance is certainly in order. ๐
Chad, I love what you’ve said here — it really resonates with where I am in my work! I’ve definitely felt the desire to work on big ambitious projects rather than the short stories everyone urges writers to begin with, but you’re right about burning out and not having the necessary experience or skills. I think I’m going to take your advice for my family history — which will benefit hugely from time anyway, because it’s going to be so much info to condense and I doubt I’ll be able to see my way to it without periods of just letting it marinate — and that’ll be good, ‘cos I won’t feel so guilty then if I’m not working on it every day, every week, all year!
I am all for cleaning the house (and our garden!), artist dates, and games too. ๐
Excellent insight and advice from someone who has been working at this for awhile. ( However, it makes me so glad I am an “in it for the joy of creating” artist, with no aspirations of trying to please anyone but myself;) — one of the perks that comes with age maybe.) Love your new book, Chad. Amazing how much detail and emotion can be conveyed in black and white.
Chad, I have to say, prior to this post I had not read Shadow Play as a whole unit; I’d only read it page by page when you were posting a page a day on your blog. So I appreciated the beautiful art, but I totally missed the storyline, until I sat down with my husband a couple of days ago and we read it together from your site. Good grief, it is so amazing, I am kind of glad I didn’t know how awesome it was before your guest post! Or I would have been so intimidated! ๐ It’s an incredible book, and so much the more powerful for having no words and no outlines; it gives our imaginations more room to roam. Thank you again for sharing it here.
Also, have you considered selling prints of the individual pages? ๐
That’s so sweet! Thanks, Lisa!
I didn’t want to get into the boring details in my essay, but I was really angry at myself for posting Shadow Play page-by-page. Soon into the process, I realized it was way too slow a pace, that no one could possibly follow the storyline at such glacial speed, and so I didn’t make any effort to publicize it when it was in that larval state.
I later realized I should have posted it in weekly chapter installments, which would have made much more narrative sense.
I know the book doesn’t break any revolutionary new ground in terms of its story, but I hope that the act of reading it is fresh and vibrant. Publishing Shadow Play and posting about it on here has given me all kinds of enthusiasm and inspiration to do a sorta-sequel. But don’t worry, it wouldn’t just tread water–I have grand, grand ambitions for it.
I had considered doing prints of some pages, particularly ones in the dream sequences, but have put that off until now, for fear of the complexities inherent in setting up a silkscreening operation. However, there’s apparently a really great local company, and I’ve been meaning to give them a call and see what they’d charge. Are there any favorites you’d suggest be made into prints?
Wow, it would have been a big change to see it in weekly installments, and I do think it would have helped with story continuity — but then there is something very impactful and lovely about getting just one panel per page, and I wonder how you could have done that in a weekly installment.
These are the ones I’d most love as prints:
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1178
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1203
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1216
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1263
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1466
http://www.chadsellcomics.com/?p=1470
I’m so glad you are still fired up about it and thinking about a sequel!! ๐
[…] There’s been a lot going on in my life this week, too! The most exciting new development is that I’ve self-published my graphic novel Shadow Play and have made it available to buy right here! And my essay about the long process behind that book was featured on my friend Lisa Hsia’s art blog. […]
this is pretty awesome. Thanks for the post and the inspiration, and good luck!
[…] Ann Arbor, Mich., resident had been frustrated with his projects that were going nowhere. He told Lisa Hsia of satsumabug.com that he was obsessing over the words, trying to make parts funny and make everything perfect so a […]