Let’s talk about fat

I’ve been at my parents’ in San Jose for about fifty hours now, and I’ve been told at least three times that I have gained a lot of weight (with accompanying hand gestures in strategic body areas) and should really lose it.

Oh, thank you for bringing this to my attention. Somehow it had escaped my notice that I am now fatter than I have ever been before. I’d never before observed that I have trouble fitting into some of my clothes, never dwelled on why I often feel tired, have trouble sleeping, or am experiencing a resurgence of my old issues with my appearance. Gee, if you hadn’t said anything, maybe I would have just gotten bigger and bigger, like a blimp, until I couldn’t fit through doors anymore! Thank you! I never would have seen that coming on my own! You’ve made me feel so much better about myself.

Yes, I’m being hurtfully sarcastic. But you know what? Comments about my looks HURT TOO. Maybe you think I’m being overly sensitive, and clearly you feel this is a problem of my own making, but I don’t need you to tell me that. Give my intellect some credit. I see you less than once a month; I see myself every day. Whatever’s obvious to you is more than blinding to me. YES, I KNOW I AM FAT. YES, I KNOW I SHOULD LOSE WEIGHT. Dammit, I’m trying, and even if I’m maybe not trying as hard as I could, that still doesn’t give you the right to say whatever you like about it.

The thing that makes me crazy about criticisms of weight gain is that, of course, they’re all based on the notion that “if you only tried harder, you wouldn’t be this fat.” Let me tell you something. We all know that weight gain has genetic and cultural components, but it does also have to do with self-control… just like when you stay up late to watch TV or go on the internet, or when you buy things you don’t need, or eat out just because it’s easier, or take out your stress on someone else who lives with you instead of dealing with it on your own. In other words, self-control problems are human. We all mess up, we all do things we know we shouldn’t, we all take it easy sometimes when life gets too exhausting. The only difference is, when you mess up on something else, you can keep it hidden. When I mess up on eating and exercise, it shows all over my body. Do I go through your household budget to point out all the times you could have saved money, like you point out every cookie I eat as evidence of how I’m not trying? It’s not fair to treat me like I’m not allowed to make mistakes, just because my mistakes are more visible than yours. Especially when I’ve trying for so long to improve. And it’s especially cruel to act as if my fatness is news to me. Haven’t I been struggling with my weight since I was ten years old? You think a week goes by that it doesn’t affect how I feel about myself?

These comments about my weight have been particularly hurtful this weekend, because I’ve been frustrated about it myself for the past two weeks. The sad truth is, I got on the scale this morning for the first time in months and I am fat, way fatter than even my last record-fat-weight, which was itself shockingly heavier than my previous record. I want to tell you the actual poundage, because I truly believe that this number is not my self-worth, but I can’t quite bring myself to do it. I know you’ll judge me on it; I judge myself. The number I saw on the scale this morning frightened and depressed me enough that I tacked on an extra half-hour of cardio to the strength workout I was already doing, and I’m going to try to keep up that level of exercise on a more regular basis. It scares me so much to see how fat I’m getting. I don’t want to gain more weight, and I don’t want to die early. I really thought I was doing better. What happened?

I have been mentally tallying my health changes this year and none of them point to weight gain. Since January, I have been doing at least three hours of yoga every week, and since June I’ve been exercising at least three times a week, often more. I eat out more rarely than I used to, and I bake far less often. I’m learning to stop eating when I’m no longer hungry, and I even turn down desserts sometimes. I eat more whole grains and more vegetables. There is no reason I should be fatter now than a year ago, so it’s deeply disturbing that I am. Every time I gain weight it makes me feel like I’m doomed to be fat forever, and I don’t think I can deal with that.

Since that encounter with the scale this morning, I’ve been thinking and thinking, and I think I might finally have it figured out. I’ve been saying for years now that if I really stopped eating when I should, I’d be eating quite small quantities, and it’s true. My meals are way smaller now than they ever were before. The problem with this is that it means I get hungrier between meals — often uncomfortably so — and I’m not a very mindful eater when I’m truly hungry. So I think, while my meals have gotten smaller, the snacks I’ve chosen haven’t been appropriate, and so I’ve probably been taking in more calories than before. The smaller-meals thing was such a huge triumph for me, I never stopped to consider how I was adjusting my snacking to compensate, and I think that’s what’s been causing the weight gain. It’s the only answer that makes sense, given all the other good things I’ve been doing for my health. So this week, besides exercising more, I’m also going to give some long hard thought to meal and snack planning. If all goes well, my weight should get back down by the end of the year, if not sooner.

Wish me luck.

[This post was imported on 4/10/14 from my old blog at satsumabug.livejournal.com.]


8 responses to “Let’s talk about fat

  1. Hello and Right There with you!

    Hi Lisa,

    I know your last commentary was about hurtful comments and I know how you feel. I too have gained too much weight this past year and now I am even going to a personal trainer. But I still like to eat too much and have my wine too. I have started to cut out a lot of things and hopefully I will get more fit. But remember do it for yourself and not for others. It is how you feel–not them!! Hope you have a better week. I need your email, I need to send an invitation to Melissa’s memorial service. Take care.

    Heather Daly

    ps: Beasley says MEOW

  2. lisa, it’s weird, this post is so timely… just this past weekend i finally stepped on a scale for the first time in months and was shocked and horrified at the amount of weight gain i saw, especially considering that i rarely eat out anymore and have even been exercising semi-regularly (at least once a week). but even though i’m not happy about it and still don’t understand it, i needed to see it. that weigh-in had such an impact that i have been waking up early every day to go running first thing in the morning, since my most common excuse to not exercise is lack of time or energy at the end of the day. who knows how long that’s sustainable (it’s only been 3 days), but while the determination is there, i need to use it. i do agree with the first comment that you have to do it for yourself and not for anyone else. we all have to find what works for us and our lifestyle, and i certainly haven’t figured it out…but just know that you are not alone.


    • Jennifer!!

      Aaah, it must be that time of the year or something when we all start weighing ourselves after the summer… good for you for running in the morning! I find the same thing; I have to exercise in the morning or else I lose momentum. Since I wrote this entry, actually, I have been trying something different and it has worked well — I exercise half an hour in the morning (the days I don’t have yoga), and then half an hour again in the evening. It’s nice because if I have to skip the evening exercise (as I did today), I still don’t feel like “I was so bad today” because I did some in the morning. And for some reason exercising in the morning makes me more motivated to do it later, too. But I agree… we’ll see how long I can sustain this. It *is* tiring to exercise and eat healthy too, when that’s not what I’m used to. But I’ve gotta do it! I’m really worried about my health if I don’t, never mind the clothes I’m not fitting into. ;b

      Thank you. 🙂

  3. I hear ya. Let’s say that Asian parents in general are not too tactful about their children’s flaws, especially in regards to appearance. It is a tearful, tearful experience and I’m sorry your parents weren’t more sensitive.

    Last year I had the same experience as you, and I couldn’t figure out why. Eventually I had to admit to myself that the mechanism that allows non-overeaters to realize when they have eaten enough is broken in me.

    So I saw a doctor and had some steady results with caloric restriction through food journaling. One of the most helpful things was weighing the dishes that I cooked, and then figuring out calories per oz (via a kitchen scale). I even measured out almonds one by one for snacks. Being anal retentive about counting calories is really tough, but it works. Frankly, all this constant work and mindfulness amounts to about a 1 pound loss per month, but I’ve gotten used to the pace. I have been using some fabulous cybertools to keep track of the weight fluctuations so I don’t freak. Let me know if you’d like to check them out.

    Weight loss is difficult, but…you can do it!

    • Hi Bright! Thank you for the comment and for reading. 🙂 I know you do really well with tracking calories, and I know other people who’ve done that too. For me, when I’ve tried it, it’s worked, but I’ve always given up because I can’t stand the constant record-keeping. (Which is weird, because I kind of love record-keeping otherwise.) I’m still hoping I can manage to lose weight if I try to do it more organically, listening to my body (which does give me signals if I stop chomping long enough to pay attention to them) and exercising because it feels good, not because I “have to”. So far, since I wrote this post, I’ve been exercising almost every day, and eating healthier and smaller meals and snacks, so I’m going to give that a month or two and see how that goes. If my weight is still up by that time, I’ll have to get more organized and start doing stuff like tracking calories.

  4. i see your sense of awareness of your weight
    i see your determination to lose weight
    i see your identification of things to change
    i see your discipline in going to yoga
    i see how intentional you are in the choices you are making.

    all those things are good, so good luck, lisa 🙂 i am sorry you got hassled about your weight this weekend. that is never fun. i am your champion in your endeavor to be healthy!

      • Re: i will never learn to properly post on your blog…

        Thank you, Alison!! I appreciate it very much. 🙂 I’m trying to be even more mindful these days, and I feel like I wake up every morning setting an intention to be healthy that day, so I hope this will work.

        Hope you and Mike are well. 🙂

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s